Ebrd Contract Award Notice

Tender/Contract Reference No: 8447899: Construction of new road of IB Category between Ulaanbaatar and Darkhan Cities.

Scope Of Contract: Construction of new road of IB Category between Ulaanbaatar and Darkhan Cities.

The scope of work includes:

Construction of new roadway of IB Category (2 lines, asphalt concrete pavement) with the total length of 202.43 km:
- Lot 1 (Contract No. UDRP-1): Construction of Ulaanbaatar - Darkhan Road Section I: 37,282 km (18.9 km – 56.18 km);
- Lot 2 (Contract No. UDRP-2): Construction of Ulaanbaatar - Darkhan Road Section II: 45,500 km (56.18 km – 101.68 km);
- Lot 3 (Contract No. UDRP-3): Construction of Ulaanbaatar - Darkhan Road Section III: 45,753 km (101.68 km – 147.44km);
- Lot 4 (Contract No. UDRP-4): Construction of Ulaanbaatar - Darkhan Road Section IV: 45,050 km (147.44km – 192.49km), including multi-span bridge crossing Kharaa River.
- Lot 5 (Contract No. UDRP-5): Construction of Ulaanbaatar - Darkhan Road Section V: 28,840 km (192.49 km – 221.33 km).


Duration of Contract: 24 months (excluding Defects Notification Period)

Contract Award Date: 22/06/2020




Lot 1


Awarded Tenderer(s):

"Arj Capital" LLC and "M-Oil Group" LLC JV

Tender price at tender opening: USD 22,604,816.53
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 19,094,060.97
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 17,050,557.28
Contract Price (in evaluation currency): USD 20,549,833.21
Contract Price (Euro Equivalent): € 18,350,528.41

Is this a JVCA: Yes

JVCA Details:
"Arj Capital" LLC
503, M plaza, Sambuu street 23, Chingeltei 5th khoroo
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, 15141
Lead partner: Yes
"M-Oil Group" LLC
10th floor, Express tower, Peace Avenue, Chingeltei 1st khoroo
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, 15160
Lead partner: No

Evaluated Tenderer(s):
China Gezhouba Group Company Limited
Gezhouba Tower, No.558 Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City, Hubei Province, P.R.C
Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City
430033
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 26,177,054.60
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 24,589,953.40
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 21,958,262.81
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Railway 20 Bureau Group Corporation
No. 89, Taihua North Road
Xi’an City, Shaanxi Province
710016
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 31,498,381.18
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 29,689,028.34
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 26,511,619.45
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Sinohydro Corporation Limited
Buliding 23,No.17,Xicui Road ,Haidian District,Beijing 100036,P.R.China
Beijing
100036
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 26,599,856.29
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Bingtuan Water Conservancy and Hydropower Construction Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
Office 1, 14/F, Building 1, Complex Building (Extended), Jinkun Tower, No. 946, South Beijing Road, Xinshi District, Urumqi City, Xinjiang, China
/
830001
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 26,033,005.09
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Communications Construction Group Co., Ltd
No.840 Wuchang Side Road, High-tech Industrial Development Zone (New Urban Area), Urumqi City, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region,China
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 30,948,469.77
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 29,083,939.06
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 25,971,288.64
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No


Lot 2


Awarded Tenderer(s):

Zhongmei Engineering Group Ltd
No.1177, Jiulong Avenue,
Nanchang city Jiangxi province
330000
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 26,337,682.31
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 25,329,916.24
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 22,619,032.61
Contract Price (in evaluation currency): USD 26,337,707.66
Contract Price (Euro Equivalent): € 23,518,967.17

Is this a JVCA: No

Evaluated Tenderer(s):
China Gezhouba Group Company Limited
Gezhouba Tower, No.558 Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City, Hubei Province, P.R.C
Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City
430033
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 32,125,919.91
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 30,996,196.66
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 27,678,890.70
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Huashi Enterprises Company Limited
No. 95, Section 2, Jiefang Road
Jinniu District, Chengdu City, Sichuan Province
610081
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 31,560,752.58
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 27,594,232.69
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 24,641,015.12
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Railway 20 Bureau Group Corporation
No. 89, Taihua North Road
Xi’an City, Shaanxi Province
710016
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 39,297,166.82
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 37,869,486.79
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 33,816,580.70
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

CHINA ROAD AND BRIDGE CORPORATION
ZHONGLU PLAZA, C88, ANDINGMENWAI DAJIE
BEIJING
100011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 31,350,551.08
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Tiesiju Civil Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
No. 96, East Wangjiang Road, Hefei, Anhui Province, China
Baohe
230041
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 21,663,386.02
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Guizhou Highway Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
Guizhou Highway Group Building, No. 8, North Jiaxiu Road, Yunyan District
Guiyang
550008
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 28,581,794.56
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 27,246,739.84
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 24,330,712.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Sinohydro Corporation Limited
Buliding 23,No.17,Xicui Road ,Haidian District,Beijing 100036,P.R.China
Beijing
100036
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 42,188,774.18
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Beixin Road & Bridge Group Co.,Ltd
16-17th Floor.Building A,Yingke Plaza, No.217 High-Tech Street,, High-Tech Industrial Development Zone
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 39,132,902.72
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Communications Construction Group Co., Ltd
No.840 Wuchang Side Road, High-tech Industrial Development Zone (New Urban Area), Urumqi City, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region,China
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 33,822,470.15
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 32,510,148.74
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 29,030,815.09
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No


Lot 3


Awarded Tenderer(s):

Zhongmei Engineering Group Ltd
No.1177, Jiulong Avenue,
Nanchang city Jiangxi province
330000
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 23,093,789.23
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 22,203,966.75
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 19,827,631.61
Contract Price (in evaluation currency): USD 23,093,813.71
Contract Price (Euro Equivalent): € 20,622,244.48

Is this a JVCA: No

Evaluated Tenderer(s):
"Arj Capital" LLC and "M-Oil Group" LLC JV
10th floor, Express tower, Peace Avenue, Chingeltei 1st khoroo
Ulaanbaatar
15160
Mongolia

Tender price at tender opening: USD 22,526,720.41
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: Yes

JVCA Details:
"Arj Capital" LLC
503, M plaza, Sambuu street 23, Chingeltei 5th khoroo
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, 15141
Lead partner: Yes
"M-Oil Group" LLC
10th floor, Express tower, Peace Avenue, Chingeltei 1st khoroo
Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia, 15160
Lead partner: No

China Gezhouba Group Company Limited
Gezhouba Tower, No.558 Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City, Hubei Province, P.R.C
Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City
430033
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 30,632,328.25
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 29,536,419.95
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 26,375,343.67
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Tiesiju Civil Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
No. 96, East Wangjiang Road, Hefei, Anhui Province, China
Baohe
230041
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 19,321,958.87
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Guizhou Highway Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
Guizhou Highway Group Building, No. 8, North Jiaxiu Road, Yunyan District
Guiyang
550008
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 23,645,172.67
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 22,698,929.60
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 20,269,622.05
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Hanil E&C & Hyundai Livart Joint Vanture
316, Gyeonggidong-ro, Namsa-myeon, Cheoin-gu
Yongin-si
17118
Korea (the Republic of)

Tender price at tender opening: USD 27,608,997.56
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 26,593,198.91
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 23,747,114.98
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: Yes

JVCA Details:
Hanil Engineering & Construction Co.,Ltd
2708, Nambusunhwan-ro, Gangnam-gu, Maesan Bulding 1st Floor
Seoul, Korea (the Republic of), 06296
Lead partner: Yes
Hyundai Livart Co.,Ltd
316, Gyeonggidong-ro, Namsa-myeon, Cheoin-gu
Yongin-si, Korea (the Republic of), 17118
Lead partner: No

Shanghai Construction Group Co., Ltd.
Room 502, No.681 Xiaomuqiao Road, Shanghai, China
Shanghai
200032
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 24,930,000.00
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 23,996,443.62
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 21,428,272.23
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Sinohydro Corporation Limited
Buliding 23,No.17,Xicui Road ,Haidian District,Beijing 100036,P.R.China
Beijing
100036
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 38,739,616.44
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Beixin Road & Bridge Group Co.,Ltd
16-17th Floor.Building A,Yingke Plaza, No.217 High-Tech Street,, High-Tech Industrial Development Zone
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 34,337,897.65
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Communications Construction Group Co., Ltd
No.840 Wuchang Side Road, High-tech Industrial Development Zone (New Urban Area), Urumqi City, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region,China
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 31,006,829.89
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 29,798,055.15
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 26,608,977.89
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No


Lot 4


Awarded Tenderer(s):

Shanghai Construction Group Co., Ltd.
Room 502, No.681 Xiaomuqiao Road, Shanghai, China
Shanghai
200032
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 25,100,000
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 23,564,240.51
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 21,042,324.79
Contract Price (in evaluation currency): USD 25,096,153.47
Contract Price (Euro Equivalent): € 22,410,287.83

Is this a JVCA: No

Evaluated Tenderer(s):
China Gezhouba Group Company Limited
Gezhouba Tower, No.558 Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City, Hubei Province, P.R.C
Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City
430033
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 28,422,281.97
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 26,819,037.81
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 23,948,783.92
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Railway 20 Bureau Group Corporation
No. 89, Taihua North Road
Xi’an City, Shaanxi Province
710016
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 35,355,527.20
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 33,467,286.75
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 29,885,517.32
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

CHINA ROAD AND BRIDGE CORPORATION
ZHONGLU PLAZA, C88, ANDINGMENWAI DAJIE
BEIJING
100011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 27,316,267.88
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Hanil E&C & Hyundai Livart Joint Vanture
316, Gyeonggidong-ro, Namsa-myeon, Cheoin-gu
Yongin-si
17118
Korea (the Republic of)

Tender price at tender opening: USD 26,597,353.94
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 25,028,127.02
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 22,349,541.78
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: Yes

JVCA Details:
Hanil Engineering & Construction Co.,Ltd
2708, Nambusunhwan-ro, Gangnam-gu, Maesan Bulding 1st Floor
Seoul, Korea (the Republic of), 06296
Lead partner: Yes
Hyundai Livart Co.,Ltd
316, Gyeonggidong-ro, Namsa-myeon, Cheoin-gu
Yongin-si, Korea (the Republic of), 17118
Lead partner: No

Sinohydro Corporation Limited
Buliding 23,No.17,Xicui Road ,Haidian District,Beijing 100036,P.R.China
Beijing
100036
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 39,956,471.75
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Communications Construction Group Co., Ltd
No.840 Wuchang Side Road, High-tech Industrial Development Zone (New Urban Area), Urumqi City, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region,China
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 30,951,506.88
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 29,152,522.31
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 26,032,531.91
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No


Lot 5


Awarded Tenderer(s):

China Gezhouba Group Company Limited
Gezhouba Tower, No.558 Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City, Hubei Province, P.R.C
Jiefang Avenue, Wuhan City
430033
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 21,619,534.6
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 19,860,079.42
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 17,734,594.14
Contract Price (in evaluation currency): USD 21,619,535.23
Contract Price (Euro Equivalent): € 19,305,747.71

Is this a JVCA: No

Evaluated Tenderer(s):
China Railway 20 Bureau Group Corporation
No. 89, Taihua North Road
Xi’an City, Shaanxi Province
710016
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 25,675,970.48
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 23,748,188.41
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 21,206,586.04
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

China Tiesiju Civil Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
No. 96, East Wangjiang Road, Hefei, Anhui Province, China
Baohe
230041
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 15,192,943.24
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 13,638,917.15
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 12,179,239.31
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Sinohydro Corporation Limited
Buliding 23,No.17,Xicui Road ,Haidian District,Beijing 100036,P.R.China
Beijing
100036
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 21,074,787.51
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Bingtuan Water Conservancy and Hydropower Construction Engineering Group Co., Ltd.
Office 1, 14/F, Building 1, Complex Building (Extended), Jinkun Tower, No. 946, South Beijing Road, Xinshi District, Urumqi City, Xinjiang, China
/
830001
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 21,684,650.56
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 0.00
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 0.00
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No

Xinjiang Communications Construction Group Co., Ltd
No.840 Wuchang Side Road, High-tech Industrial Development Zone (New Urban Area), Urumqi City, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region,China
Urumqi
830011
China

Tender price at tender opening: USD 25,545,744.51
Evaluated Tender Price (in evaluation currency): USD 23,563,704.58
Evaluated Tender Price (Euro Equivalent): € 21,041,846.22
Reason For Rejection: n/a

Is this a JVCA: No


Other Information: Reasons for rejection of tenders:

Arj Capital LLC (Mongolia) and M-Oil Group LLC (Mongolia) JV [Lot 3] – non-responsive to ITT Para 4.8 [offered Lots 1 and 3 while prequalified for single Lot only, Tender for Lot 3 was rejected].

China Road and Bridge Corporation (China) [Lots 2, 4] – non-responsive to ITT/TDS Para 19.2 [validity period of Tender Security shorter than required].

China Tiesiju Civil Engineering Group Co., Ltd. (China) [Lots 2, 3, 5] – non-responsive to ITT/TDS Para 32.2 [considered abnormally low].

Sinohydro Corporation Limited (China) [Lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5] – non-responsive to ITT Para 11.1(h), 28.4 [Technical Proposal non-responsive: ESHS Code of Conduct – not acceptable; QAP, ESHS Plan, C-ESMP – omitted certain topics].

Xinjiang Beixin Road & Bridge Group Co., Ltd. (China) [Lots 2, 3] – non-responsive to ITT Para 4.3(d), 4.3(e) and TDS Para 11.1(ii)(i) [affiliated with another tenderer through the same parent company].

Xinjiang Bingtuan Water Conservancy and Hydropower Construction Engineering Group Co., Ltd. (China) [Lots 1, 5] – non-responsive to ITT Para 4.3(d), 4.3(e) and TDS Para 11.1(ii)(i) [affiliated with another tenderer through the same parent company], non-responsive to ITT/TDS Para 19.2 [validity period of Tender Security shorter than required].